Is amnesty for "Dreamers" worth it if we get a border wall?



President Trump offered a deal to Democrats on Twitter: If they agree to a border wall, an end to chain migration, and an end to "lottery visas", which lets in unskilled people nearly at random, he will agree to legalize the so-called "Dreamers".

Democrats seeking a deal to protect so-called Dreamers from deportation must be prepared to agree to a package that includes several White House priorities, including a border wall and reforms to the U.S. immigration system, President Donald Trump wrote on Twitter Friday morning.

“The Democrats have been told, and fully understand, that there can be no DACA without the desperately needed WALL at the Southern Border and an END to the horrible Chain Migration & ridiculous Lottery System of Immigration etc. We must protect our Country at all cost!” Trump tweeted.

What do you think of Trump's offer? I have some concerns about it.

What President Trump seems to be offering is legalization for the "Dreamers" now, and building of the wall to come. This has a number of potential pitfalls:

1) Since a border wall cannot be built in one year, it cannot be funded all in one year. Democrats could agree to fund it for a year as part of a deal to legalize Dreamers, but next year prevent further funding for continued construction. For those of you who remember the last amnesty, given by President Reagan, it was supposed to be accompanied by the construction of a border wall, but Democrats simply never funded it.

2) President Trump wants an end to chain migration. Does this mean that while simultaneously legalizing the "Dreamers", he is going to deport their parents? I think politically, that is very, very unlikely to happen, in which case what we are really talking about is amnesty not just for Dreamers, but for all illegals, which is a much higher price.

3) Obama approved "Dreamer" status for nearly all those who applied with all the vigorous vetting of a Democratic hack working in a passport office in Kabul. Will these "Dreamers" be more closely scrutinized? Will the ones who have committed crimes (other than illegal entry) be denied legal status? Will there be some sort of distinction made concerning the crimes that are "acceptable" and those that aren't, and what will those lines be? How long will "Dreamers" have to wait to become citizens?

4) In his tweet, the President makes no mention of mandatory E-Verify to keep illegals from taking American jobs. I think a mandatory, enforceable E-Verify is as important as a border wall.

5) President Trump talks about ending lottery visas, which is a good step, but didn't mention the much bigger issue of revamping our legal immigration system to (a) reduce the number of immigrants admitted yearly and (b) prioritize those with high level skills.

6) What about ending birthright citizenship? President Trump talked about this repeatedly on the campaign trail, but hasn't said a word about it since elected. I think this alone is more important than a border wall... though it would be nice to have both.

Conservatives have always operated from the presumption that the border should be secured first before any talk of amnesty for those within our borders illegally. Otherwise that creates another perverse incentive for people to flood across the border before we have secured it. That's why I think a proposal to restore legal status for the "Dreamers" now and to build a wall later is not such a good deal.

[originally in AT]



Related articles:
Does anyone who applies for asylum truly need it anymore?

Guess which country recently built a 1,700 mile wall to keep illegals out?

Obama Sending Diseased Refugees to Red States








Does anyone who applies for asylum truly need it anymore?


Once upon a time people, who applied for asylum in America came from communist dictatorships in Eastern Europe or the Soviet Union and often had legitimate reasons for fleeing. If they expressed political opposition to the regime in power, they often faced torture, imprisonment, or even execution. That's why America allowed anyone coming into the country to apply for asylum, even if they entered illegally, delaying deportation until a hearing could be held.
CONTINUE READING

Related articles:
Guess which country recently built a 1,700 mile wall to keep illegals out?

Obama Sending Diseased Refugees to Red States

Supreme Court, with Dumb Donald's and Paul Ryan's help, will legalize illegals




The flu shot is largely worthless and possibly dangerous


Every year the "gubment" inveighs us to get our flu shots. It's our civic duty!
CONTINUE READING Related articles:
The flu vaccine is probably useless

Soccer player giving brain to science; democrats to follow

NYT sounds cautionary note on self-decapitation, freezing of brain



Guess where high school dropouts can make $400 an hour


In this week's imaginary career advice column, one reader writes:
CONTINUE READING Related articles:
Commie Judge calls right to work a confiscation of union property

Wisconsin Unions complain they can't buy elections anymore

Scott Walker pushing bill making it easier to fire bad bureaucrats



The secret for bookstore survival in the Amazon.com era


"Another one bites the dust! Another one bites the dust!"
CONTINUE READING Related articles:
How not to save a dying shopping mall

Why is Sears dying?

If you want to know why Amazon.com is opening bookstores, don't ask the NYT



How does marriage turn women into Republicans?


The liberal media always finds it helpful when a liberal Republican parrots one of their major themes and Senator Jeff Flake of Arizona was only too happy to oblige.
CONTINUE READING Related articles:
Doctor Who officially replaced by Nurse Who

Bestselling YA Novel features superpowered girls, sex slave boys, and a girl-God

Preposterous "Breakfast Date Rape" case shows the extremes of liberal hysteria



Theresa May loves Muslim migrants, paying Brexit ransoms, and trangendering James Bond


I have concluded that the only thing conservative about British Prime Minister Theresa May is her hemlines. Her position on Muslim immigration and her capitulationist positions on Brexit have given me doubt. But the last straw was her position on a woman James Bond.
CONTINUE READING

Doctor Who officially replaced by Nurse Who


The actor playing Doctor Who, the British sci-fi character who has been played by various men for 54 years, has just been replaced by a woman, who I am calling Nurse Who, which, I assure you, is meant with all due respect. For those of you who are fans of science fiction, this trend of performing gender reassignment surgery on male characters is not an unfamiliar one.
CONTINUE READING Related articles:
Bestselling YA Novel features superpowered girls, sex slave boys, and a girl-God

Preposterous "Breakfast Date Rape" case shows the extremes of liberal hysteria

Women's prisons control bad girls with tampon reward system



Bestselling YA Novel features superpowered girls, sex slave boys, and a girl-God


Have you been looking to own a copy of Naomi Alderman's young adult book "The Power"? You may have trouble finding it, because it's been flying off the shelves.
CONTINUE READING Related articles:
Doctor Who officially replaced by Nurse Who

Preposterous "Breakfast Date Rape" case shows the extremes of liberal hysteria

Women's prisons control bad girls with tampon reward system



Lib experts: Execution of terrorists will only make Islamists angrier and angrier


The Times reported that Egypt executed fifteen Islamic terrorists, but, predictably, the Times worried that the executions would only make radical Islamists commit more acts of terror.
CONTINUE READING Related articles:
NYT: If Jesus were here, he's spend Christmas with Lesbians

Rohingya Muslims in desperate need of protection from Rohingya Muslims

Many American Jewish "leaders" deaf, blind, and dumb to Islamic Kristallnacht



Libs blame Russia, not themselves, for racial, gender, class warfare propaganda


On the PBS NewsHour yesterday Laura Rosenberger, a foreign policy advisor to Hillary Clinton and George W. Bush (not a typo), said (starting at the 6:30 mark) that Russia is trying to turn Americans against each other, "playing on racial divisions, political divisions, issues like immigration... trying to undermine the fabric of our democracy by pulling us apart at the seams."
CONTINUE READING Related articles:
NYT, down on Trump's "sexual harassment", reinstates sexual harassing reporter

What's happening to Breitbart?

NYT tries to torpedo purchase of TV stations by conservatives




Next Page





Search Topic Areas
o Donald Trump
o Best articles
o Abortion
o Economy
o Education
o Environment
o Hairy feminists
o Gay agenda
o Gun control
o Illegal aliens
o Pop culture
o Radical islam
o Republicans
o Reverse Racism
o Ted Cruz
o Transvestite agenda




NewsMachete.com Copyright 2015
Feedback


Who is NewsMachete?

Privacy policy
Search Topic Areas
o Donald Trump
o Best articles
o Abortion
o Economy
o Education
o Environment
o Hairy feminists
o Gay agenda
o Gun control
o Illegal aliens
o Pop culture
o Radical islam
o Republicans
o Reverse Racism
o Ted Cruz
o Transvestite agenda